You’re Not Here by Accident
Something brought you to this page.
Maybe it’s a tenant problem. A rent raise that made no sense. Maybe you’re trying to buy your first rental and you don’t want to screw it up. Or maybe you’re just tired of not being taken seriously by the people managing your money, your property, and your time.
Whatever it is, let’s be honest: you’re here because you want something better.
Better service.
Better communication.
Better outcomes.
That’s what we do.
Rentals for Real Life. Management Built for Peace of Mind.
📍 Serving Greensburg, PA & surrounding neighborhoods
We Are Not…
We’re not some giant corporate company who only contacts you through AI call bots.
We’re not the people who heavily edit their rentals until they look artificial.
And we don’t treat our customers as objects who make us profit.
We treat others like real people. We provide truthful information. And we care for our properties and our clients.
If you want:
– A massive faceless company that takes weeks to call you back
– A “one-size-fits-all” service with surprise fees at every corner
– Or sloppy tenant placements and even sloppier maintenance
Then we are not your people.
But if you want clarity, care, and a company that treats you with respect then you just found the place for you.
Who Are We?
Atherholt Investments is a property management company grounded on one principle:
“Take care of people, and they’ll stay.
Take care of property, and it will grow.”
It’s not a revolutionary concept, but it is lacking in most companies.
Led by Kristi Atherholt, a licensed realtor, local investor, and formal Navy veteran, we manage each rental like it’s our own. Because many of them were.
Over the past decade, Kristi has helped hundreds of renters settle into reliable homes and dozens of owners unlock real value from their properties without the chaos.
First-class Professionals
What You Can Expect From Us
You walk in. The air’s clean. The locks work. The lights turn on without a flicker. You open the fridge and it hums, quietly, because it’s fully functional.
The experience continues to be just as pleasing.
Something breaks? You let us know and we fix it promptly, without three follow-ups and a customer support ticket.
Need clarity on a lease? We’ll walk you through it.
Worried about tenants wrecking your asset? We vet, screen, and place the right people.
This isn’t big-box management. It’s a locally run business that works hard to ensure you have the best experience.
What Do We Offer?
Reliable, clean homes.
Every rental is professionally maintained, properly turned, and inspected top to bottom. We don’t list anything we wouldn’t personally live in.
Fast, direct responses.
You won’t be sitting on hold. You won’t be ignored. And we will get back to you fast and clearly.
Hands-on management.
We’re not outsourcing care. If something’s off, we’re in it with you until it’s right.
A partner, not a pipeline.
No corporate ladder. No bots. Just humans, doing honest work and following through on promises.
And If You’re Still Deciding…
That makes perfect sense and we respect you for that.
You should be cautious.
There’s a lot of noise in real estate and plenty of empty promises.
So take your time.
Ask tough questions.
Compare us to the rest. Look at the details, the systems, the reputation.
And when you’re ready, come back.
We’ll still be here. With our same philosophy:
Take care of the people. Take care of the property. Everything else follows.
Have any questions?